Wednesday, 2 May 2018

Klopp of the Class

I watched Gary Neville's Monday Night Football awards this week and I found it very hard to disagree with any of his decisions, or indeed anything he said at all. It was en excellent synopsis of the season from a top notch pundit.

For him as a fan it must have been difficult heaping so much collective praise on Manchester City, and a certain individual at Liverpool. For him as a pundit, it was probably the easiest set of selections for his annual 'awards' that he has ever had to make. 

Whilst I respect his opinion and admire his outstanding contribution to punditry over recent years, I have to disagree on one of Neville's choices, and that is for the Manager of the Year. This next section sets out my reasons why Pep Guardiola, in my opinion, would come third on this list, behind Sean Dyche (in second), and Jurgen Klopp (in first). 

Choosing Klopp may seem a controversial decision, Liverpool are after all, probably where most people expected them to be this season, albeit with the addition of a likely Champions League final. However, there are three key reasons, for me, why Klopp ranks above Guardiola in the managerial rankings this season:

1. Full Backs
The role of the full back has changed over the years and has become such a big part of the modern game. Manchetsre City spent almost £125m on three full backs this summer. When you have a warchest that size, the arguments will always be there that you have simply bought the title. Whilst i don't strictly think this is true (Neville himself highlighted the improvement of certain individuals already in the squad), the amount of money spent on three full backs was a clear indication that Manchester City were willing to invest in a title challenge this year. Liverpool, on the other hand, spent £8m on a wee Scotsman from Hull, and have promoted youth with the ever-growing talent that is Trent Alexander- Arnold. Given the differing styles of play of the two sides, I'd argue that Liverpool's first choice full backs (at £116m less than Man City's) have been no less effective in helping their side achieve their relative success this season. The example of the full backs serves also to demonstrate that the budget Senor Guardiola is working on is far greater, not just than Klopp, but than any of his rivals. It was quoted on the opening day that Manchester city have spent more money on full backs than Brighton did on their 30,000 all-seater stadium - enough said! 

2. Head to Head
The fact remains that Manchester City are the best team in the land right now. To beat them once this season is an excellent achievement, to beat them twice is quite phenomenal, but let's remember, Liverpool have beaten Manchester City THREE times this season. The league game at Anfield in January was scintillating and one that will live long in the memory, and Liverpool ran out deserved winners on the day. The two Champions League legs were both special games too, and Liverpool thoroughly deserved their victory over the two legs, with Klopp masterminding a plan to nullify the champions at Anfield, and then ensuring that they delivered on the mantra that "scoring at the Etihad will end the tie". It did. The Champions League performance at Anfield, particularly the first 30 minutes, was a pure masterclass that, if Liverpool go on and lift eh Champions League, will be played over and over again. Klopp seems to be the only manager this season who has really "got one over" on Guardiola.


3. Man Management - the Coutinho Affair
Let’s face it, Guardiola hasn’t exactly had a difficult season in terms of handling his squad.  Why would he? The way in which Liverpool, and Klopp, managed the sale of Phillipe Coutinho was outstanding. Everyone knew he was leaving, and he was ready to go, but he still put in some of his best performances in a Liverpool shirt when Barcelona could so easily have been on his mind. Don’t underestimate how much of that is down to Klopp.  Then after the sale, the players who had formed the “Fab Four” with Coutinho each upped their own game and helped Liverpool maintain their outstanding form, including fellow Brazilian Roberto Firmino, who would have felt the departure of his countryman more than most. Don’t underestimate how much of that is down to Klopp either. Finally, the money used from the sale of Coutinho was invested very wisely indeed with the acquisition of Virgil Van Dijk - filling a void at centre half for Liverpool that they have waited so long (too long) to fill. To top it off, Van Dijk scored a late winner in an FA Cup Merseyside derby on his debut.

So there you have it, three reasons why Jurgen Klopp, in my opinion, deserves to be considered Manager of the Year, ahead of Pep Guardiola. Yes, Klopp has made mistakes along the way, the goalkeeping issue for one, but in terms of the overall job he has had to do this season in "managing" his team, my view is that Klopp's efforts outweigh those of Guardiola - who, with City, has had a relatively comfortable time of it.

I also mentioned Sean Dyche earlier in this piece, who deserves another mention as we draw to a close. To achieve a top seven finish with his Burnley side is nothing short of incredible, especially when you consider the relative budgets of Burnley and Man City. What Dyche has put together at Burnley, is build a great team spirit - it's fantastic to see such a wonderfully nostalgic approach to management still succeeding in the modern game.

In summary, you have three managers who have all built great teams in very different ways, none of these ways is more right, or more wrong than the others, but all are built with the foundations and the philosophies of the managers who lead them. Guardiola's approach to total football is no doubt aided by the bottomless warchest he has available in the transfer market, Klopp's approach is very easy to buy into - though it would seem that his transfer dealings have been much more successful than the likes of Conte and Mourinho, and in Dyche, a good old fashioned Englishman building a team based around hard work and team spirit. But, for all the reasons above, Klopp just has the edge this season for me. 

No comments:

Post a Comment